I can think of few better places for me to have emerged from
my enforced exile and back into the world of pubs and beer, than the Brecknock Arms at Bells Yew Green.
On Sunday the pub was
the venue for West Kent CAMRA's Good Beer Guide 2019, selection meeting, and
whilst my interest in the Guide these days is rather limited, the meeting
seemed the perfect occasion for me to turn up and re-commence my involvement in
branch activities.
The Brecknock has hosted West Kent
branch selection meetings for several years now, the main reason being the pub lies
in neutral territory, just across the county border in East Sussex.
It is also easily accessible by train (Frant station); an important consideration given the
high quality of the Harvey's beer
stocked there, and its obvious appeal to branch members. If this were not
enough, the landlord allows us the use of the former saloon bar area, once the
dining trade has petered off.
![]() |
Frant station - just three stops from Tonbridge |
Yesterday though, there was no food trade as the chef had
called in sick. This was bad news for those branch members who had arrived
early, in order to grab a spot of Sunday lunch prior to the meeting. I was
unaffected because I would be eating at home, later that evening. Even so, I picked
up a roll plus a coffee from Greggs, before boarding the slightly delayed 13:08 train.
I arrived at the pub shortly after 1.30pm, pleased to see a CAMRA contingent already present.
This was the first time since before Christmas that I'd seen any of my drinking
buddies, and rather ironically that last get together was our CAMRA branch
Christmas meal, which also took place at the Brecknock. It was therefore good
to catch up with all the gossip, over a few pints of Harvey's
Old.
The main purpose of the meeting, of course was to select the
branch allocation of 22 pubs for the 2019 Good Beer Guide. Eleven members were
present, plus a couple of apologies, along with recommendations in absentia. The
proceedings were presided over by branch chairman Craig, who did well in keeping
the discussions focussed, and not too bogged down in the detail.
In order to speed up the selection process and cut down on
possible areas for dissent, the branch committee had set out firm criteria for selection, in line with CAMRA's Policy Document on
Good Beer Guide entries. The number of visits to each pub, as obtained from
Whatpub, along with NBSS scores submitted, were all taken into account, along
with general branch knowledge of each particular pub plus feedback from the
surveyors. It was here that input from the meeting was especially useful, and was
where I was able to voice my opinions.
In just under two and a half hours 22 firm entries had been
finalised along with three reserves. The latter being ranked 1 - 3, depending
on final allocation. This was from a total of 50 pubs nominated and surveyed. Some
pubs (just under half ) were obvious candidates, and were selected without
dissent, whilst others required re-visiting (metaphorically speaking), involving
further discussion.
Without blowing our own trumpets too much, we all felt
satisfied that we had approached the task as logically as possible, and had
been as objective as we could. Obviously personal preferences can and do come
into play, but we were all conscious not to let our feelings have too great an
influence on the overall decisions being taken.
Being blessed with an abundance of excellent pubs in West
Kent, we had the opposite problem to branches who struggle to fill
their allocation; but this meant we were able to approach the task from a
position of strength. Despite my limited interest in the Good Beer Guide, I
went away feeling pleased with the final selection, and content that the pubs
chosen would appeal to both regular and occasional users of the Guide.
Finally, a quick word about the Harvey’s
beer at the Brecknock, which was in excellent form. The XXXX Old Ale was
especially good and I scored it as 4.0 NBSS. I rated the Best at 3.0, having
been spoiled somewhat when compared against the quality of the Old.
There was a small crowd of locals in the bar that afternoon,
but the absence of the chef obviously decimated the Sunday lunchtime food
trade. Our presence therefore, must have provided a welcome boost to wet sales, so I’m
certain that Dave the landlord must have been glad we were there.
I too was pleased I’d gone along, and was equally glad I’d
limited myself to just three pints. After nearly six weeks of limited or very
moderate consumption, that was just the right amount to ease myself back into
the world of pubs and beer.